Baltimore Key Bridge Collapse

How safe are Bay Area bridges?

In the wake of a bridge collapse in Baltimore, many are wondering about the Bay Area's bridges.

NBC Universal, Inc.

The Golden Gate Bridge Authority issued a statement reassuring commuters of the safety of the iconic Bay Area bridge, saying it has the most robust ship collision protection of any bridge on the west coast.

The announcements came hours after a container ship lost power and rammed into a major bridge in Baltimore on Tuesday, destroying the span in a matter of seconds and plunging it into the river in a terrifying collapse that could disrupt a vital shipping port for months. Six people remained unaccounted for on Tuesday afternoon as the search for survivors continued.

Back in the Bay Area, Caltrans issued a similar statement to what the Golden Gate Bridge Authority released, saying bridge safety is a high priority.

Local structural engineering experts said residents should be reassured about the integrity of bridges in the region.

"In the Bay Area we have several beautiful bridges that are strong enough to withstand any kind of reasonable situation," said Farzad Shahbodaghlou, an engineering professor at California State University East Bay.

Shahbodaghlou said Bay Area bridges are engineered to withstand massive earthquakes and even typhoons. But he admits you cannot design for every possibility, like a direct hit from a massive container ship.

In the wake of a bridge collapse in Baltimore, many are wondering about the Bay Area's bridges. NBC Bay Area’s Raj Mathai spoke to Farzad Shahbodaghlou, a professor of civil engineering and construction at Cal State East Bay, about what safeguards the eight major bridges in the Bay Area. 

However, Bay Area bridges may be less vulnerable to the collapse in Baltimore. According to civil engineers, one of the most protective features of Bay Area bridges in particular is the shallow depths of portions of the bay itself. That is because most of the supporting piers of many Bay Area bridges, including the Golden Gate Bridge and the Bay Bridge, are built in shallow parts of the bay where massive cargo ships like the one in Baltimore would run aground before making a direct impact.

"The Dumbarton Bridge -- ships can't get to that place, it's so shallow," said Hassan Astaneh, a retired UC Berkeley engineering professor. "The Richmond-San Rafael Bridge is a little bit deeper, but it's shallow for this kind of ship."

The 1.6-mile Francis Scott Key Bridge crossed over the Patapsco River in Baltimore where its namesake was inspired to write the words of the American national anthem, “The Star-Spangled Banner,” in 1814.

Astaneh noted a collision has happened in the Bay Area. He studied the crash of the Cosco Busan container ship into the Bay Bridge in 2007. The ship sideswiped one of the Bay Bridge's support piers and caused a massive fuel spill.

In the 2007 incident, the protective bumper around the support pier was damaged, but the bridge itself was not harmed.

Since that crash, engineers have been designing massive circular structure called "dolphins" to protect bridge piers.

The Baltimore incident is still under investigation and it is not clear if those protective structures could have helped.

Six people are presumed dead after that tragic bridge collapse in Baltimore, Maryland. But, could something like this happen in the Bay Area? NBC Bay Area’s Jocelyn Moran spoke to engineering experts and also has an update on the people still missing.
Contact Us